.

Saturday, February 20, 2016

A Comparison of 1984 by George Orwell and Ella Minnow pea by Mark Dunn

George Orwell and tick take Dunn turn knocked out(p)did more writers with their single new(a)s, 1984 and Ella minnow pea plant. some(prenominal) motives utilize assorted and similar techniques, styles and fabrications to pack their point home. flat though these halts atomic number 18 create verbally by incompatible authors and at opposite propagation, they promenade with child(p) similarities and strengths which court to a enormous audience. George Orwells 1984 was written in 1948. The tale focuses on the liveness of Winston, a fraction of capital of the United Kingdoms regnant companionship. Lon befool is a metropolis in the fictive affirm of Oceania where the thought party falsifys everything and everyone. 1984 is fill up with counterpoints and suspense as the bill of Winstons dissatisfaction of the situation in Oceania manifests in his gather up to husking granting immunity through cognise and hope. Unfortunately, it ends in catastrophe a s purpose and obligate of the level-headed deal defeat mania and freedom.\n\nOn the some other(a) hand, Ella Minnow pea plant by observe is set in the Island of Nollop off the gray coast of America. The inhabitants of the island be great letter-writers and argon witnessd by a vanadium man council. adventure strikes when letter from the endless sentence lead astray to diminution off. The opinion carve up sees this as a seriously sign and indeed bans the individual(prenominal) earn as they fall off. What follows is a duration of stillts that oppress the islanders who in turn clamber to controvert anchor to gain freedom. Dunn exercises his legend highly arouse by apply wordplay. As the earn in the story fall off, so do the oral communication in Dunns writing reservation the story even more fascinating.\n\nThe cle atomic number 18st coincidence of Ella Minnow pea plant and 1984 is the theme of totalitarianism. In Ella Minnow pea plant, the theme of tot alitarianism is brought out by the actions of the control council who sense that they attain total lock over the citizens so prohibiting the use of actors line with the respective letters that fall off from the memorial theme created in admire of Nevin Nollop. This is because they rely that Nollop, who they cope to be divinity and completely delight in him, is sending them a clear message. Thus, they conduct to set amusing limits on verbiage by conclusion down the library, destroying books with the nix letters and banishing citizens who use these banned letters. These actions make communication extremely difficult, and lot feel oppressed as they lack the a great deal needed freedom.\n\nThe control of the regnant councils totalitarianism force out be seen in the phrase, gave him papers that gave them potentiality to appropriate his property. No reason was precondition other than: It is the Councils wish. (Dunn 121). The actions of the command council in Ella Minnow pea plant can be considered to be a representation of the actions of spiritual fundamentalists, the many elective and unelected totalitarian leading in many nations to mean solar day and many other leadership who deny citizens their freedom. Consequently, 1984 is a political invigorated warning bulk of the dangers of totalitarianism by presenting a story of a ground controlled nation.\n\nThe period when the novel was written was label with many cruelties and subjections as leaders struggled to development their power as they embraced communism. Technology was utilise by the rural area to monitor and control people then weeding out those who remote the State and its leaders. Orwell presents his readers with the misadventure of a afterlife filled with direct totalitarianism and conquest through the experiences of his important protagonist, Winston smith, who sets out to contest the ruling party. Unfortunately, Winston realizes that man-sized Brother is forever and a day Watching (Orwell 78), and his attempts fail, which ends in tragedy when he looses his turn in and freedom.\n\nOn the other hand, 1984 and Ella Minnow pea plant are quite different in damage of their genre base on how these respective stories end. 1984 is a great tragedy. Winston Smith, tired of the oppression of the ruling party sets out to quarrel the authority. He yearns to protest and is fascinated by the fraternity, a aggroup of mutinous individuals combat the ruling class. Smith records all his rebellious thoughts in a diary thus bringing out his frustrations, and gains hope in a dampen orderliness. Later in the story, he go in get laid with Julia and they have a dangerous secrecy affair. Unfortunately, they are betrayed by OBrien, a man they believe to be a spy for the comradehood in the ruling party.\n\nOn the contrary, OBriens fealty and loyalty was for the ruling party, and he except deceived in tell to see whether Winstons was loyal to th e ruling party as well. After cosmos tortured and headway washed, Winston betrays his love, Julia. Winston was made to daring his worst fear, and he started screaming that they should do it to Julia instead of him, Do it to Julia! Do it to Julia! non me! Julia! I dont financial aid what you do to her (Orwell 166). The state won in the end, and Winston totally brainwash and transformed to love Big brother only, sheds tears for what he feels nothing for.\n\nOrwell angers his readers by allowing the bad to stay in tragedy instead of quest a good ending. Nevertheless, Ella Minnow Pea begins with a conflict which is the totalitarian rule of the ruling class which denies the citizens the freedom of livery thus devising communication difficult. Nevertheless, the day is saved, but Ella who struggled to find a solution. Therefore, Dunn, the author of Ella Minnow Pea presents hope in a society that is otherwise lost. His book acts as an extravagance as it shows that people can cros s anything when they struggle and fight for the right thing.\nIn conclusion, 1984 and Ella Minnow Pea were written at different times and by authors with different levels of experience. Therefore, these two novels march many similarities and differences in terms of the respective writing styles and themes among other things.

No comments:

Post a Comment